
Cyberpsychologist Dr. Nicola Fox Hamilton warns that blaming victims of scams can lead to deeper harm and silence. Speaking at IRISSCON 2026 in Dublin, she emphasized that such blame discourages victims from reporting future incidents.
Fox Hamilton, a researcher and lecturer at IADT, highlighted the lasting impact of scams on victims. She stressed that anyone can fall victim to cybercrime, stating, “We are all potential victims of cybercrime at some point.”
The Role of Shame in Keeping Victims Silent
According to Fox Hamilton, the aftermath of a scam is just as critical as the initial incident. Whether it’s losing savings to an investment scam or falling for a phishing email, shame often prevents victims from speaking up.
She shared a personal experience to illustrate this point. While completing her PhD at IADT, she received an email prompting her to update an old password. Despite her expertise, she fell for the scam. “As soon as I hit the button, I knew what I’d done,” she recalled.
Her reaction was harsh: “I’m so stupid.” However, she later realized it wasn’t stupidity but vulnerability that led to the mistake. She said “But it’s not stupidity, it’s catching you in a moment of vulnerability, which everybody has at some point.”
Read Also: Cybersecurity job market sees surge in specialized roles
Optimism Bias and Overconfidence Increase Risk
Fox Hamilton explained that many people underestimate their risk of falling for scams due to optimism bias. This belief that “Bad things are much more likely to happen to other people than me” leads to victim blaming and increased vulnerability.
Standard advice about scams, such as never sending money to someone you haven’t met, often misses the mark. Scammers build trust over months, making victims believe they’re in a legitimate relationship. “And when somebody you’re in a relationship with asks you for money, that’s very socially normal,” she pointed out.
The Devastating Aftermath of Scams
Scammers isolate victims from supportive networks, often by portraying friends and family as jealous or unsupportive. This isolation, combined with the loss of money and trust, leaves victims feeling deceived and powerless.
The emotional toll is severe. Shame, fear, anxiety, and depression are common, and in extreme cases, victims of romance or sextortion scams have experienced suicidal thoughts or taken their own lives.
The impact extends beyond individuals. A study from the Philippines linked widespread cybercrime to lower trust in institutions and increased social isolation.
Read Also: Vodacom reports strong half year revenue growth
In organizations, employees often view phishing tests as traps rather than learning opportunities. Fox Hamilton urged security teams to reframe these tests as tools for identifying training gaps and to respond to failures with support and education.
Fear of blame drives people to hide mistakes, which is particularly dangerous in cybersecurity. Every month of silence after a phishing incident gives attackers more time to exploit the network.
Scammers’ Tactics to Isolate Victims
Scammers employ strategies to cut victims off from supportive networks. They tell victims that relatives questioning the relationship are jealous and don’t want them to be happy. This isolation makes victims more dependent on the scammer.
Scammers also let victims do most of the talking, gathering information to use later while avoiding inconsistencies in their own stories. “Being listened to is very powerful,” she noted.
Leave a Reply